Showing posts with label Various. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Various. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 23, 2014

The end of innovation?

An American scientist, Jan Vijg, from the Einstein College of Medecine of New York, revived the discussion on science which has traditionally opposed optimism and pessimism. In a book called "the American technological challenge",  he has elaborated a detailed graph, reproduced recently in a journal  which compiles a list of 300 macro-inventions from 500 B.C. until 2010 and which demonstrates that innovation reached a peak in the 70s then declined in following decades. 

The author of the research has, nevertheless pointed out that it is not technological decline but a slow down of the pace of innovation. This trajectory may have some commonality with other evolved civilizations, such as China under the Song dynasty or Islam in the Middle Age. One of the causes may be saturation. According to a study by Jones and Azoulay from MIT, an average R&D worker was seven times more productive in 1950 as one today in terms of contribution to innovation and growth, probably because he could focus on frontier research rather than keeping up with scientific developments in his own field - and this why there more people working in R&D than in the past. 

However, the main obstacles to innovation are cultural factors. Relative welfare improvements lead to a lesser aversion to risk, and the institutions tend to slowdown, rather than stimulating technological development.  Hence the question : what can be else invented? Are we really condemned to give the best of our intelligence and creativity to make small improvements to inventions made by others in the past? True, we cannot ignore the great transformation of the Seventies- the music, the desire to change the world, the civil rights and so on - and the big technological push with the invention of the personal computer (1975), the cellular phone (1978), the walkman (1979) and even the first project of Internet by Tim Berners-Lee (1980).  

R. Gordon supports the idea that big innovation is behind us:  in a recent article, he suggests that the process of economic growth as it happened over the last 250 years will not persist forever. The sources of economic progress may derive from other factors such as education, energy gains or demography rather than innovations.

Are pessimists such as Vijg and Gordon right? The Economist argues that there are strong arguments for a certain optimism. The first one is that there is a time lag of 5 to 15 years between the investments in technology and the improvements in productivity levels. Therefore, the most modern technologies are actually not reflected in current statistics (as Solow used to say about information and communication technologies which are everywhere but in productivity statistics). The second argument is that new technological developments are hindered by rigid institutions which block the potential for growth and productivity.

The debate is quite complex as it involves both historical and spatial dimensions. If they are more innovations, it does not mean that they will have a greater impact today. Moreover, globalization of technology has resulted in stagnant incomes and declining employment in the US and Europe. As Marx and Schumpeter explained, the crisis of capitalism generates a tendency toward technological progress as part of a process of 'creative destruction' but it does not mean that innovation alone will be enough to boost growth and may coexist with a prolonged period of stagnation. 

Just a final note. A few centuries ago, Niccolo Macchiavelli wrote: 

There is nothing more difficult to take in hand, more perilous to conduct, or more uncertain in its success, than to take the lead in the introduction of a new order of things. For the reformer has enemies in all those who profit by the old order, and only lukewarm defenders in all those who would profit by the new order, this lukewarmness arising partly from fear of their adversaries … and partly from the incredulity of mankind, who do not truly believe in anything new until they have had actual experience of it.

Sunday, April 27, 2014

Beyond GDP: a new measure of growth

Since the 40s, GDP  measures output from the 'use' side , that is the  value of all 'final' goods and services used by consumers, businesses and government. It gives a biased view of the economy as it neglects the role of intermediate goods. 

The US Bureau of Economic Analysis has launched the 'gross output" measure to measure the total value of sales in all phases of economic activity, from raw materials, intermediate goods to final products. This measure was introduced by Wassily Leontieff in the 30s at the level of individual industries , but not as an aggregate measure. One of his disciples, Mark Skousen, presidential fellow at Chapman University and author of the book "Structure of Production" (New York University Press 2007) argues that this is a more reliable measure of total economic activity. In his view, the traditional measure of GDP has contributed to the idea that consumption is the real motor of the economy, as it represents more than two-thirds of it and that savings are unproductive. In fact, economic activity in the intermediate stages of  production - including capital formation, technology and business spending - is largely underestimated. The new measure  also provides a better understanding of business cycles. Nominal US GDP fell by 2% while gross output declined by 8%; conversely, it has risen faster than actual GDP . 

The question is what could be the consequences on the other economies in Europe and Japan, if gross output is generalized. Since gross output emphasizes the 'make' economy rather than the 'use' economy, it gives more weight to capital investment, innovation, entrepreneurship and productive savings. This indicator will  'reward' countries like Germany or Italy which have a tradition of manufacturing and a high propensity to savings (despite it has been hardly affected by the crisis). Therefore, economic policies will tend to focus more on production rather than purely on demand stimulation, which is not to be neglected, though.. 

It is certainly a decisive step forward to a better measure of growth. However, it is still not a radical reform like the measure proposed by Stiglitz, Sen and Fitoussi,  focusing on quality of life rather than on material components of wealth. 




Friday, December 6, 2013

Tribute to Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela, 1918 – 2013

Nelson Mandela passed away last night at 95. He was one of the greatest men of History alike Ghandi and others. He achieved peace without violence with those who kept him in prison  for 26 years. What is more important than giving hope to his people, oppressed by one of the worst regimes ? 

But we should also value peace not just for moral reasons but also because it represents a motor of progress. As Europeans we know what this means and how peace and reconciliation gave rise to an unprecedented era of prosperity.  In South Africa,  living standards have improved substantially for all, but the balance is still disproportionately in favour of white population and Asian South Africans.

As the Economist points out: "Under its own majority rule, the lot of the ever-growing black population—today forming over three-quarters of the national total—has been notably poor. Misguided governance, low-quality education, skills shortages and massive unemployment levels of around 40% have left it more disadvantaged today than when Nelson Mandela was still behind bars. Black income has virtually flat-lined, betraying tremendous gulfs between the wealth of the different racial groups. Sadly, the nation Mandela leaves behind today remains one of the most unequal in the world".

Mandela has paved the way to democracy and human rights in a divided country. He left a better world for all of us and for his country but there is still a long way to equality. As he wrote in 1970 during his imprisonment, " social equality is the only basis of human happiness.”   

Rest in Peace

  

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Albert Jacquard: a utopian humanist

Albert Jacquard was a scientist who studied population genetics and worked long for the WHO. But he was known for his humanism and activism in defense of the weakest. He was obsessed by the idea that we should act to leave a better world to our grand-children. 

In 1978, he published 'L'Eloge de la Différence- la génétique et les autres" where he argued that all men were different from a genetic point of view. But none of these differences was a justification that a human group was superior to any other.  Becoming a member of the National Consultative Ethics Committee, he fought vigorously against racist arguments developed by far right extremism. 

Lately, he became an activist for human rights.  His engagement was expressed in a simple sentence : " devenir soi nécessite un détour par les autres"  ( to become oneself requires a detour through others). His reckless fight for the homeless to give them a home contributed to raise awareness among the population of the situation of people deprived of civil rights.  

In 2009, he participated to to another initiative, the Russell Tribunal on Palestine,  to reach a fair and durable settlement of the israeli-palestine conflict. His last battle was for a total nuclear disarmament together with Stéphane Hessel , an idea he defended since he ran for an ecologist list for the European elections in 1999. 

Prof. Jacquard was convinced that another model of society is possible. He considered that 'competition undermined the foundations of society" and denounced  the abuse of the word ' competitiveness' on which current policies are founded. He was a utopian but a realist one. 

France has lost one of his best men. Our hope is that many will take over his ideas and engagement . 

R.I.P. 

Wednesday, December 26, 2012

Public Education is our Common Good


Profit is the motor of capitalism. Where there are business opportunities, private sector tends to step in. This principle also applies to the education  sector. The economic crisis and the dogma of austerity which prevails in Europe has as an immediate consequence a reduction of public expenditure in welfare policies such as education or health. Lower investment from the State opens the door to private capital. 

Risk capital has a long experience in investing in education, especially in anglo-saxon countries and northern Europe. In southern countries like Spain or Italy, private equity operations are not so developed, but there is growing interest from the business sector in a context where public investment in education is likely to fall significantly in coming years. The shortfall, which could be, for example in Spain , around 10-11 billion € will be only in part compensated by wealthier families. History tells us that when public investment falls private investment tends to crowd in and vice versa. In fact, one of the main arguments of protests against austerity is to combat privatization and the risk of dismantling public education to the benefit of private initiative. 

Available data on profitability of private colleges and universities do not compare well with other economic sectors. The fall of household income tends to shift students from the private to the public sector as families cut spending in education for their children. However, investment firms acknowledge that education is  particularly sensitive  because clients are the children and their parents. Risk capital firms will step in if it is a stable business based  on foreseeable cashflows over the schooling cycle of students and therefore can provide leveraging. Considering that the duration of private equity in a business varies between 4 and 10 years, the education sector offers a sufficient margin for for making investments profitable in the medium term. This means, that public-private partnerhips could develop as it has already happened in healthcare sector.  

While governments  ensure that budget cuts are essential to sustain the public education system in the medium to long term, opponents to austerity believe that they are taking advantage of the crisis to put more money for education in the private sector. Having exhausted the main sources of business and profit such as the construction and public works and industry remains unattractive because it needs large investments, private capital seeks new business opportunities or expands the existing ones. In that sense, basic services such as education or healthcare offer relatively safe profit opportunities. 

The real problem is that a too large involvement of the private sector may endanger the fundamental right to education as citizens will turn from owners of these rights in users of a private system that they will afford according to their economic possibilities. Some organizations support private investment in education but not for all ages. In the early stages of education where investment brings high social returns, public budgets should intervene in financing education.  


Investing in education increases well being and productivity but also yields positive  returns for the society. According to some empirical estimates by Angel de la Fuente (2011), the social returns to investment in human capital are higher than those on physical capital in most EU countries . Of course, outcomes vary across countries depending on both quantity and quality of human capital investment. However, there is no evidence that private education systems will be better performing. Nordic countries invest a much larger proportion of their GDP in public education with better results than the rest of EU countries. A better educated population means a more productive economic system, and therefore more able to compete globally. It's not a matter of  privatizing education systems. 

Sunday, November 11, 2012

One dollar, One vote

Henry Stern, the founder and president of New York civic writes on his website: "Elections are the best way to decide public issues in a democracy. The word 'democracy' means 'rule by the people' , which is a fair and determine which policies a government should follow, and who should be elected to lead that government. A basic principle is one man, one vote" which is meant to support the idea that each citizen's influence should be equal. In reality, some people's influence is greater than others, no matter what system of reckoning is used. The most obvious barometer of influence is money. A man who can give a million dollars to a candidate is much more likely to be listened to than a contributor of $1. It would be impossible to write a law under which every citizen’s views would receive equal attention and respect. But it remains a legitimate goal of reformers to minimize the disparity in resources between candidates.The major distinction between citizens and interest groups lies in their access to candidates. A substantial amount of public business is transacted at fund-raising events for the benefit of individual candidates. Clearly, these events provide contributors with an opportunity to meet with the candidates they support and to try to influence them".


In economics, 'dollar voting' means a process of capital allocation through consumer sovereignty. Ludwig von Mises wrote (in Socialism, an economic and social analysis (1922), tr. J Kahane (1931), p 428 ) : "The capitalist society is a democracy in which every penny represents a ballot paper. 

Obama has won the US elections with a moderate discourse. As the Economist points out, the American poor were hardly mentioned in his re-election campaign. In 2010, 15% of the American population live below the poverty line (around 44% of the median income), well above the OECD average of 6% (see chart below). 




Anti-poverty programmes have allievated the impact of the crisis for the poorest 20% and helped consumer spending. Redistribution is not popular in Almerica, especially among Republicans who want to cut food stamps in order to reduce federal spending. Who defend the poor? Well, they don't have many lobbysts unlike banks or other industries. 

The "one dollar, one vote" result provides an explanation for the increasing difference in the size of the welfare state in Europe and the US. The rise of the rich's income in the US has in fact allowed the rich to increase their political influence and get policy issues closer to their interests which is to limit redistribution to the poor and reduce the size of the welfare State. As a result , poverty has increased at a faster pace and redistribution lagged compared to Europe.

In the mid-50s, a plutocrat, H.L.Hunt had proposed a 'one dollar, one vote' system which would allocate votes based on the voter's wealth and 'contribution to society'. Nowadays, there are more sophisticated forms to increase political influence through money.  This contrasts sharply with equality of opportunity which was at the heart of the American identity. One dollar, one vote is the failure of democracy.